The Maryville Daily Times reports that a lawyer for the Tennessee Division of Elections has advised Blount Co. Election Commission that a "special election" to fill the General Sessions Court judge vacancy is not allowed according to a 1984 Attorney General ruling and that County Commission must appoint a replacement.
According to the article, the Tennessee Division of Elections lawyer was not aware of the same scenario in Knox Co., in which Knox County is planning a November election to replace a General Sessions Court judge who was elected to Circuit Court. The lawyer said "maybe" it has something to do with Knox County's home rule charter.
Knox County's home rule charter Article IV, Sec. 4.02 says "If a vacancy occurs in any judicial office of the General Sessions or Juvenile Court, or in any other County judicial office established by law or by this Charter in Knox County, then that vacancy shall be filled by a vote of the Commission as prescribed in this Charter, and the person so selected shall serve until his/her successor is elected and sworn."
It would actually seem more clear that Knox County cannot hold an election. (Unless the charter means for the appointment to be temporary until the next election. The charter does not appear to be as specific as state law on that.) On the other hand, state law applies in Blount County case, and state law seems to directly contradict the Tennessee Constitution. Guess somebody needs to fix that.
It should also be noted that the November election is not a "special" election. It is a regularly scheduled general election. So it's not clear if the 1984 AG opinion applies. In fact, state law specifically states that vacancies occurring in a 120 day window before the November election are to be filled by party convention nominations and a November election.
But we assume nobody will press the issue with Blount County to seek further clarification, and they will do whatever they want to do as usual.
Topics:
|
Discussing
- Krystal on Alcoa Hwy near the Airport has closed (1 reply)
- Alcoa Hwy - Hunt Road Interchange Redesign (1 reply)
- Jackie Hill! Jackie Hill! She won! (1 reply)
- Blount County Democrats hear from candidates (1 reply)
- Vote for Jay Clark for TN House of Representatives-District 8 (1 reply)
- Where's the dang ammo plant? (1 reply)
- Little River in Townsend has a commercial tubing problem (1 reply)
- Springbrook Farm - ALCOA West Plant Contamination (1 reply)
- Another Alcoa West Plant plan on display - Thurs. Sept. 28, 2017, 5 PM (1 reply)
- Raccoon problems in Blount County (3 replies)
- Downtown Maryville slammed by storm (1 reply)
- Maryville residents must refrain from doing laundry (1 reply)
TN Progressive
- Price Gouging by Big Pharma (TN Citizen Action)
- Exposed: Insurance Insider Explains Industry Games (TN Citizen Action)
- The Next Subprime Crisis (TN Citizen Action)
- Whistle Blower Reveals Asbestos Dump at Kingston TVA (RoaneViews)
- Stop the Block (TN Citizen Action)
- Fallout Shelter Inside Gated Community Given Historic National Register Tax Credit (RoaneViews)
- Friday Toons Via Juanita (RoaneViews)
- Make America Great Again Yet? (RoaneViews)
- Santa’s boo boo (Domestic Psychology)
- Love you too, dear (Domestic Psychology)
- NoBloNo (Domestic Psychology)
- Another correction for the Daily Times (BlountViews)
TN Politics
- Nashville and Shelby County Still Weighing Voucher Lawsuit (Nashville Scene)
- Women Say Belmont Law School Discriminates Against Pregnant Students (Nashville Scene)
- Cooper Announces (Another) Plan for Police Body Camera Rollout (Nashville Scene)
- Tennessee Representatives React to Articles of Impeachment (Nashville Scene)
- Tennessee Historical Commission adds 8 sites to National Register (TN Journal)
- The Execution of Lee Hall (Nashville Scene)
- McNally statement on execution of Lee Hall (TN Journal)
- Tennessee Executes Lee Hall for 1991 Murder (Nashville Scene)
- Roe says he’s undecided about re-election bid to Congress (TN Journal)
- Lee signs order moving disability services for young children out of Education Department (TN Journal)
- Lee signs proclamation declaring Rosa Parks Day in Tennessee (TN Journal)
- Vandy baseball team declines White House visit (TN Journal)
Knox TN Today
- Vacation destination: Transiting the Panama Canal is a lock (Knox TN Today)
- Howard and Barbara Phillips: Doing a lot better (Knox TN Today)
- Girl Scouts create snow characters (Knox TN Today)
- HABIT vols bring good cheer (Knox TN Today)
- Fulton Comic Club a platform for artists and writers (Knox TN Today)
- State fails to spend funds earmarked for poor Tennesseans (Knox TN Today)
- Adventures growing up in Fountain City: The Marine Pirate legend (Knox TN Today)
- Memories of Cas Walker fill hair salon (Knox TN Today)
- Kincannon announces top hires; Welch to resign from council (Knox TN Today)
- A bowling we will go (Knox TN Today)
- Pinnacle at Turkey Creek draws visitors, serves community (Knox TN Today)
- Saturday was kids day, all day in Powell (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- New sports facility to open in Lonsdale, bringing the community together (WBIR)
- Knox County Sheriff’s Office searching for missing teen (WATE)
- All day sunshine with chilly afternoon temps. (WBIR)
- East TN road conditions mostly mild as rain turned to snow overnight (WATE)
- Second Harvest gears up for ‘Double Your Donation’ Day; partner organizations talk about its impact (WATE)
- Five Days of Giving: Ending hunger in East Tennessee (WBIR)
- LCSO searching for ‘real life Grinch’ after caught on camera stealing packages off porches (WATE)
- Victims Remembrance Tree service honors loved ones (WATE)
- TDOT prep roads for winter weather (WATE)
- Gatlinburg's 'Library Cat' needs a loving home to live out the rest of his days (WBIR)
- Job fair gives students glimpse into their futures (WBIR)
- Knox County Juvenile Court's stuffed animal supply replenished one week after asking for donations (WBIR)
News Sentinel
- Snow again? Knoxville covered in third snow fall of season in photos (KNS Business)
- Wednesday classes canceled and delayed in East Tennessee due to winter weather (KNS News)
- I decided to go public with my mental health struggles. Here's what happened. | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- They had one year. Now these UT students have 3 ideas to stop suicide on the Natchez Trace Bridge (KNS News)
- These Knox County restaurants had perfect inspections in the last half of 2019 (KNS News)
- Why we celebrate International Human Rights Day in Tennessee | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- TVA investigates contamination concerns, plans new coal ash dump at Cumberland power plant (KNS News)
- Cumberland University history professor: A citizen's guide to how impeachment works (KNS Opinion)
- There are many reasons we sing the praises of Tennessee | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- It's time to move the Nathan Bedford Forrest bust from Tennessee's Capitol, GOP leader says (KNS News)
- Benchmark solution is free market answer to address surprise medical billing | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- Knox sheriff's office slammed for 'shameful' record keeping system on ICE documents (KNS News)
- As the Broadway viaduct comes down, learn how it began | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- Knoxville Biz Ticker: Mast General Store to release downtown-branded merchandise 'A Knoxville Christmas' (KNS Business)
State News
- Watch Memphis teacher greet each student with individual handshake to begin the day (Commercial Appeal)
- Franklin family in 'unimaginable pain' after mother, son found dead in home, police say (Tennessean)
- They had one year. Now these UT students have 3 ideas to stop suicide on the Natchez Trace Bridge (Tennessean)
- Hamilton County Sheriff's deputy indicted on criminal charges - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Penny Hardaway, Rick Barnes de-escalate rift ahead of Memphis vs Tennessee Vols basketball game (Commercial Appeal)
- TVA investigates contamination concerns, plans new coal ash dump at Cumberland power plant (Tennessean)
- From NLE Choppa to Kevo Muney, 5 Memphis rappers to watch in 2020 (Commercial Appeal)
- Scuba Claus visits Tennessee Aquarium - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Study predicts Chattanooga will be the country's hiring capital in 2020 - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- With Nashville's MLS stadium progress stalled, Mayor Cooper and team owner meet to discuss hurdles (Tennessean)
- City Beat: Christmas pageants are always a good time - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Mike Norvell writes thank you note to Memphis, will not coach Cotton Bowl (Commercial Appeal)
Local .GOV
- City Crews Make Memories for Thousands Every Holiday Season (Knoxville)
- Garth Brooks Loves Knoxville. We Do Too. (Knoxville)
- UT 2019 Homecoming Parade Celebrates 225 Years of "Lighting the Way" (Knoxville)
- At PolitiCode, Knox Students Do the Teaching (Knoxville)
- City Hosts Regional Community Development Conference (Knoxville)
- Coming Down: Jackson Avenue Ramps Replacement Project Off to Quick Start (Knoxville)
- Knox County to host 21st Annual Holiday Festival of Lights (Knox County)
- KCHD releases Middle School Youth Risk Behavior Survey (Knox County)
- I.C. King Park Ribbon Cutting Set for Oct. 24 (Knox County)
- KCHD resumes #WeCanForLeeann Campaign (Knox County)
- Third annual observation of Pregnancy and Infant Loss Remembrance Day planned (Knox County)
- KCHD's next Diabetes Management Series will take place in October (Knox County)
Wire Reports
- A statue of a black man on a horse has a new home in the heart of the Confederacy - CNN (US News)
- There’s a huge change coming from the Fed (just not today) - MarketWatch (Business)
- US consumer prices increase more than expected in November - CNBC (Business)
- Jersey City shootout: Mayor says kosher deli was ‘targeted’ by gunmen - The Washington Post (US News)
- Biden indicates he would only serve one term as president: report | TheHill - The Hill (US News)
- Suspects targeted kosher supermarket in Jersey City shooting rampage, mayor says - USA TODAY (US News)
- Jersey City shootout, Trump slams "impeachment lite,' and a record Yankees' contract: The Morning Rundown - NBCNews.com (US News)
- Saudi Stock Exchange CEO on Aramco IPO - Bloomberg Markets and Finance (Business)
- IHOP is opening a fast casual restaurant called 'Flip'd' - CNN (Business)
- Fed Likely to Hold Rates Steady After Busy Year - The Wall Street Journal (Business)
- Chevy's 2021 Tahoe and Suburban add OTA updates and big screens - Engadget (Business)
- Federal Judge Blocks Diversion Of Military Construction Money For Border Wall - NPR (US News)
- Real estate company shares $10M bonus with employees - Fox Business (Business)
- San Francisco’s ‘poor street conditions’ a factor in city’s loss of $64M Oracle tech conference: reports - Fox News (Business)
- Pete Buttigieg releases list of McKinsey clients - CBS News (US News)
Local area websites:
Blount DemsMC Democrats
Raven Society
League of Women Voters
Wendy Pitts Reeves
Stop Alcoa Parkway
KnoxViews
Knox Dems
RoaneViews
TennViews
TN Clean Water Network
TN Dems
Government websites:
Blount CountyCity of Alcoa
City of Maryville
State of Tennessee
TN Code Annotated
TN General Assembly
UT CTAS
UT MTAS
Media websites:
Maryville Daily TimesKnox News Sentinel
Again, let the people not vote
Randy:
I'm not buying this argument re: the Tennessee Division of Elections. I agree that "[i]t would actually seem more clear that Knox County cannot hold an election" based on your post. I suppose that I am exhausted with the dictates that come from Nashville that would deny the Blount voters an opportunity to select their own judge.
Just my opinion; opinions are what they are, but I am a lawyer but a free speech advocate first. If there's an opportunity, lets not give up this issue.
TFM
Thomas F. Mabry
P. O. Box 52385
Knoxville, TN 37950
Fax 1-888-215-3119
Phone 1-865-671-0598
um.. certainly not 'special'
(link...)
§ 2-14-106. The county legislative body shall be required to make an appointment to fill a vacancy within one hundred and twenty (120) days of receiving notice of the vacancy unless during that time period there is a general election scheduled in the county and there is sufficient time for the vacancy to be placed on the ballot in accordance with this section.
We should be allowed to vote for the new Sessions Judge.
Sounds pretty definitive to
Sounds pretty definitive to me. So what's up with the Division of Election? Selective AG opinion reporting?
head pounding....
It would be really freaking nice if the State Party got involved about now, eh?
You want me to mail that check where?
Date set to select new Sessions Judge
Commissioner Reeves has the info- (link...)
Pursuant to and in accordance with the provisions of Tennessee Code Annotated 5-5-113, notice is hereby given that the Blount County Board of Commissioners will hold an election as authorized by Tennessee Code Annotated 5-1-104 at 6:00 p.m. at the Blount County Courthouse in Maryville, Tennessee, on September 9, 2008, to fill the anticipated vacancy in the office of General Sessions Judge, Division IV. "
Side note- there is NO TCA 5-5-113 anymore. That bit of code was deleted from TCA by the May 2008 passing of Public Acts, Chapter 871.
Local rules! Local rules! We don't need any kind of stinkin' local rules! No matter what branch of government we are going to make up our own rules! We ARE Blount County!
there is no tca 5-5-113
I do not think this is correct, notice the verbiage "The provisions of this subdivision shall not apply in any county having a population of not less than 897,400 nor more than 897,500 according to the 2000 federal census or any subsequent federal census."
This was built to have an affect on probably one county....Legislatures way to amending into or out of a legislative act, make it apply based on population figures of certain census.
Keep reading
You are quoting from the updated TCA 5-5-104
5-5-111 should apply to BC. I don't see how Blount County would be excluded from this chapter.
(h) This section shall not apply to any county which has a metropolitan form of government and a population in excess of five hundred thousand (500,000), according to the 2000 federal census or any subsequent federal census.
(i) This section shall not apply to any county having a population of not less than 897,400 nor more than 897,500 according to the 2000 federal census or any subsequent federal census.
Re: Keep Reading
Actually I was quoting from the 2008Public Acts, Chapter 871, bill directly.
It can be found at http://state.tn.us/sos/acts/105/pub/pc0871.pdf
I am sure you have read this but others may have not.
yeah..almost there
Chapter 871 makes changes to several sections of code. Your quote is from a new subsection to 5-1-104 and that does not apply to BC as noted. The rest of the changes in 871 do apply to BC.
5-1-104 is what gives the Blount County Commission the power to make appointments.
5-5-111 is how the BC Commission at the minimum shall make the appointments. Those new rules spell out that nominations shall be permitted from registered voters of BC.
SECTION 3. Tennessee Code Annotated, Section 5-5-111 is amended by
deleting the section in its entirety and substituting instead the following:
This is one nice piece of legislation as it opens the doors of vacancy appointments to the public. Let's all say thanks to Knox county!
Seems like somebody ought to
Seems like somebody ought to get this info to Commissioner Reeves or Libby Breeding or somebody.
the fustration
Like a monkey in a tree full of fruit, the at home activist has to climb all over the place to find bits of code and put it all together.
The very large backside of the elephant can simply bump up against the same tree and all the fruit falls to their feet.
The monkey does not pay for services such as westlaw but the elephants use county money for the service.
That which takes the at home activist hours and hours to find, they have at their fingertips. So, yes, I am frustrated that the powers don't even appear to use those advantages.
(link...)
Knox County seeks AG Opinion on open Sessions Judge seat
Knox County is asking for an AG Opinion on whether they may have the open Sessions Court seat on the Nov ballot. As seen on many other AG Opinions, the question will be formatted so that no matter what applies to Knox it will not hold water in Blount.